Saturday, February 24, 2024

How To Sell My Baseball Cards

Must read

Should I Get My Cards Graded Before Selling Them

How to Sell Baseball Cards

A graded card is nearly always worth more than a ‘raw’ card that is ungraded.

Before sending your cards to a third party grader, you must evaluate the potential increase in value after grading the card.

If the costs to grade outweigh the increase in value, it is not worth grading.

This raw ungraded Dr J rookie which I would estimate in VG 3 conditon sold for $220 on eBay.

This PSA VG 3 Dr J Rookie sold for $400 on eBay, a $175 premium to a very comparable raw version.

Bare minimum grading costs now run from $25 to $50 at the cheapest levels.

And cheaper levels of service tend to take much longer than expedited, higher priced grading tiers.

If you want to sell your collection quickly, grading your cards might not be in your best interest.

A card worth $50 that might see a $25 bump after grading is not worth the hassle of grading due to the costs involved.

If it’s worth $150 or more, it’s probably worth grading, but I’d probably use a bulk submission to get a discount on the grading price.

For premium, high priced cards, the costs to grade will be much higher, but the increased premium from grading will be well worth it.

I will note that a majority of collectors today only buy graded cards, thus a graded card is much easier to sell than a raw counterpart.

I’m usually only in a rush to send my cards off to the grading companies unless I want an immediate opinion on authentication.

How Can I Tell If My Baseball Cards Are Worth Anything

One of the best ways to learn everything there is to know about baseball cards and sports trading card collections is to immerse yourself in the collector community. Learn everything there is to know about the community of collecting and selling cards by joining local meetup groups or even online groups, forums, and active communities.

You can share information regarding the cards you have with other baseball card collectors near you , pawn shop owners, and even individuals who run various baseball card-collecting websites and organizations.

Spend time researching the cards you have in your possession individually to learn more about their value, demand, and whether or not it is best to list and sell them individually or as part of a package deal.

Ask avid baseball fans and collectors for their opinions and advice, and seek out resources from others who are known in the collectors business online and with local connections. The more familiar you become with the realm of baseball card collecting and sports memorabilia, the better luck you will have when it comes time to sell and promote the cards you intend to sell.

Be Careful Of Scammers

If selling your cards to someone online without any prior connection, you need to be careful. Consider places such as Facebook and other for-sale sites such as Craigslist and Offer Up.

If accepting digital payments, understand that Paypal Goods and Services will entail a fee but provides protection for both buyers and sellers.

If meeting in person, find a local police station that allows for online exchanges. Check with your local police dept to see if they offer the option.

If you don’t want to list on eBay or work with an Auction House, there are dealers that will pay top dollar for high-quality sports cards.

One happens to be us here at All Vintage Cards . Below is some more information on our buying process:

Read Also: New Balance Men’s Pl4040v5 Tpu Low Molded Baseball Cleats

Best Places To Sell Baseball Cards For Cash

by Lauren Bennett – Verified & Updated May 10, 2021


Want to know where to sell baseball cards? If so, then this is the post for you.

Perhaps youve been collecting baseball cards for a while and want to sell your collection?

Or maybe you inherited some cards from a family member and want to know where you can sell them?

Or perhaps you were just clearing out the garage and came across some cards that you forgot you had?

Whatever, the case, if you have some baseball cards that you no longer want, then you should definitely consider selling them.

Thankfully, just like we showed you in our where to sell basketball cards post, you have lots of options when it comes to selling cards and sports memorabilia.

Need Easy Extra $300+/Month for Free?Panel PaydayInboxDollarsDaily Goodie BoxBranded SurveysTolunaSwagbucks

In todays post, Ill cover places where you can sell your baseball cards online and near you.

What will I learn?

What’s The Most Sought After Baseball Card

How To Sell Baseball Cards

9 of the Most Valuable Baseball Cards in History

  • Honus Wagner | Card Sold For: $6,606,000. …
  • Mickey Mantle | Card Sold For: $5.2 Million. …
  • Babe Ruth | Card Sold For: $4,212,000. …
  • Mike Trout | Card Sold For: $3.9 Million. …
  • Nolan Ryan | Card Sold For: $600,000. …
  • Jackie Robinson | Card Sold For: $392,400.

Also Check: Baseball T Shirts For Men

Tips For Selling Your Sports Cards

Now that you know what places buy sports cards, here are some selling tips you can keep in mind!

  • Focus On Research: If you have valuable sports cards, you really need to do your research so you have an accurate idea of how much your cards are truly worth.
  • Consider Selling Time: Selling on markets like eBay or at auctions helps you get the best price. But this also requires more time versus selling sports cards to companies like Beckett or Dave & Adams, so consider the trade-off between time and value.
  • Get Appraisals: For rare sports cards or anything autographed, you should consider getting an actual appraisal so you know the value and authenticity of your cards.

Extra Reading How To Get $500 By Tomorrow.

Selling Baseball Cards For Quick And Easy Cash

Selling baseball cards is an easy way to make money on the side.

Now that you know how to sell baseball cards, you can apply what you learned to similar vintage sports card collections plus other collectibles, sports memorabilia, and vintage items.

For example, if you have a box of old basketball cards, football cards, or hockey cards, follow the same guidelines above to see if you can profit off your stash.

We hope youre able to find some hidden gems in your collection and make top dollar for your cards.

If youre interested in selling other items online, make sure to check out our guide to selling tech gear and selling anything else you can think of online.

Brett Helling is the founder of He has been a rideshare driver since early 2012, having completed hundreds of trips for companies including Uber, Lyft, and Postmates.

Since that time, he has expanded his knowledge into the Gigworker site, as well as writing the book Gigworker: Independent Work and the State of the Gig Economy Paperback, .

You May Like: Columbus Ohio Baseball Tournaments 2022

What Are The Most Valuable Baseball Cards Ever Sold

The price of any baseball card directly depends on its rarity, condition, and collectors value. You may have seen some cards fetching exorbitant prices while some cards sell for a mere dollar or so.

But there are several such baseball cards exist that can even fetch a million dollars. And five of the priciest baseball cards ever sold are as follows.

Ty Cobb Tobacco $1,100,000

Join InboxDollars to earn up to $50 per survey & 6+ other ways to make money. Claim a $5 Instant Signup bonus.

The Four Eras Of Baseball Cards

How to Sell Baseball Cards Online

Baseball cards are generally classified into four eras. Although the exact definitions of these eras may vary from expert to expert, you will find the Deans Cards parameters consistent with almost any other source of knowledge. Since the year of a card heavily influences value, cards from certain eras are treated differently and you should adjust your expectations for financial return accordingly. Click on these links to read more about the era, or eras, in which your cards fall.

Deans Cards does not buy cards newer than 1980. However, some hold value. To read more, please click the link above.

Read Also: Mizuno Adult Men’s Premier Players Baseball Pant

Are Baseball Cards From The 80s And 90s Worth Anything

But the fact is, very few sports cards from the late-1980s through to the early-1990s have much value. In fact, many are hard to give away today. But not all hope is lost for those looking to cash in on their sports card stashes from the era. See also: The Top 30 Baseball Cards from the Junk Wax Era.

Where Can I Find The Value Of Baseball Cards For Free

Free Baseball Cards Price Guide Options5 Places to Find Card Values

  • Card Mavin: Simple, clean interface powered by eBay results. …
  • Sportscard Database: Requires a free account to view prices based on market data and a value algorithm.
  • eBay: Easy, familiar. …
  • PSA: Best source for graded card book value.
  • Don’t Miss: Most Valuable Baseball Cards 1990s

    How To Sell Basketball Cards

    This article was co-authored by wikiHow staff writer, Kyle Hall. Kyle Hall works on the content team at wikiHow. He helps manage our team of editors and creates content for a variety of wikiHow projects. Kyle continually looks for new ways to improve the content at wikiHow and make it more helpful and enjoyable for readers. He graduated from Eckerd College in 2015, where he majored in Political Science. This article has been viewed 41,610 times.Learn more…

    Selling your basketball card collection can be an exciting process, especially if you think you have some rare and valuable cards. Thanks to the Internet and a growing interest in sports card collecting, selling basketball cards is easier than ever. The key is figuring out the value of your cards and then finding the right buyer.

    How To Sell Your Trading Cards

    How To Sell Baseball Cards On Ebay / Best Places To Sell Baseball Cards ...

    Written by Top Cash Buyer on August 6, 2021. Posted in Collectibles, Art, and Antiques

    Do you have old trading cards stored in the attic of your home? Would you like to sell your sports cards but have no idea where to begin? If so, now is a great time to learn how to sell those cards and earn some extra cash. Depending on the type of sports cards you have, the era theyre from, who they feature, and their overall condition, you might be surprised to learn how much they are worth.

    Selling your trading cards is not as difficult as you might think, especially with the help of online auction sites and websites like eBay, Craigslist, and Facebook. Keep reading to learn how to sell your trading cards.

    Also Check: St Louis Cardinals Baseball Tonight

    Is Selling Baseball Cards Still Profitable

    The main concern many have when getting into this hobby is how soon theyll make their first million.

    Although you cant guarantee youll make it big selling baseball cards: if you play the slow and patient game, you can make thousands.

    As with any business, the main skill you need to make money selling baseball cards is to be able to recognize a great deal and be able to mark it up, and follow through with a sale.

    This means investing wisely in which cards you think will turn a profit and how much money you know youll be able to make for them.

    You will need to be aware of the marketplaces to sell your cards and details that effect profits such as why eBay fees are so high.

    Many treat buying and selling baseball cards like a lottery they luck into when they make a good sale: but this is a quick way to throw away tons of money.

    Buy carefully and sell intelligently.

    The average successful sports card trading business can generate profits between $30,000 and $50,000 within its first couple of years.

    If you want to make a six-figure income, youll have to be patient to build up to it. In the meantime, it can be a fun way to make money in college without a job.

    What If I Am Just Not Ready To Let Go

    If you are not to the point where you can emotionally part with your boyhood memories then my advice is not to sell. Especially if you do not have any ideas for how to use the money, as you would probably be better off letting your cards continue to accrue value over time rather than putting your returns in a savings account with almost no interest. Many collectors keep the cards until they die and let their heirs worry about what to do with the collection. We certainly understand a mans attachment to a boyhood sports card collection.

    That being said, refusing to sell your collection simply because youre banking on their value increasing is not necessarily a safe bet. After all, that is what everyone said about internet stock a few years ago and we all know how that played out.

    For more information, check out this page dedicated entirely to this topic:When NOT to Sell Your Baseball Card Collection

    Read Also: Fourth Of July Baseball Game

    The Best Way To Sell Sports Cards Can Look Different For Everyone

    When you look up, how to sell my baseball cards, youll find that there are different routes for different scenarios. The guide above will help you better understand what to look for and where to go when youre ready to sell certain cards in your collection.

    Are you looking to build your collection as well? If so, nows the time to discover new sports cards here at Giant Sports Cards! Founded by fellow collectors. Shopping with Giant Sports Cards comes with the added benefit of speedy, free shipping on orders over $175, great customer service, and $10 off when you sign up for our newsletter. Explore our hobby boxes and cases now!

    Are Counterfeit Baseball Cards A Problem

    Dean’s Cards – How to Sell My Baseball Cards

    Generally no. Vintage cards are hard to fake and any scam generally comes to light quickly.

    Your biggest concern would be making sure listings are accurate when buying online.

    The scammy switch-a-roo is unfortunately a grift that still happens when it comes with buying/selling baseball cards.

    Or selling sports card in general: football cards, hockey cards, basketball cards, and really any sports memorabilia, etc.

    Making sure autographs are authentic is the other concern. But there are ways to get your cards graded by a professional sports authenticator.

    Also Check: Baseball Gloves Made In Usa

    Selling Modern Baseball Cards

    People who are looking to sell baseball cards that were issued after 1980, and expect to make a lot of money, are often in for a rude awakening. This article provides some insight on what to do with modern baseball cards, what they are worth, who buys them and where to take them.

    The quick answer is: We do NOT buy individual cards newer than 1975 or Complete Sets newer than 1985.

    Please do NOT call us about Post-1980 cards. We have no information and would be overwhelmed by the volume of these calls.

    The only place that we know of to sell your post-1980 sports cards is that we know of is marketplaces like: Ebay or For the values of modern sports cards please see the free Tuff Stuff Price Guides.

    Another thing that has hurt the value of the modern cards is that “Mom” no longer throws them away when you move out of the house, like she did in past issued after 1980 are almost worthless!Unfortunately, there are only a few sets from after 1979 that Dean’s Cards can purchase.

    How Do I Start Selling Baseball Cards

    Learning how you can sell cards online and the best way to sell sports cards is not often an overnight task. Immersing yourself in the collector community of baseball cards is the first step to truly understanding the value and demand of your own card collection.

  • Organize your collection by date, type, name, and even the condition of the individual cards you own.
  • from your boxed cards or sealed card collections.
  • Research the baseball card community to determine the value of your card.
  • Choose a platform that is geared towards your type of baseball card.
  • Request an appraisal from your preferred selling platform.
  • Create and monitor your listing to begin selling your baseball cards.
  • Don’t Miss: Dave Henderson Baseball Card Value

    Or Send Your Collection To Us

    Dibbs makes it easy to turn your physical card collection into fractionalized assets so people all over the world can own a piece of baseball history. We’ll even cover the shipping! Create a Dibbs account today and start selling and trading your cards on the world’s only real-time 24-7 fractional collectible market.

    Nila Lê

    Nila Lê is the Senior Content Manager at Dibbs. Nila’s PC is comprised of Pokémon TCG, NBA and WNBA cards, as well as pop culture NFTs.

    Local Card Show As A Dealer

    How to Sell a Collection of Baseball Cards â Collectors Universe

    Another option for selling your cards at a card show is to set up shop on the other side of the table.

    For a small fee, you typically get access to an eight-foot table where you can spread out your cards and make them available to all the patrons milling through the show. That gives you more eyeballs ogling your actual, live cards than you can find through just about any other method on this list.

    When you set up at a show, you get to set your asking prices, too, and you can decide just how low youre willing to go for any given card.

    And if you dont sell your cards? Or not as many as you want?

    Just pack them up and try again at a later show. Or with one of the other methods here.

    But, while setting up at a card show has lots of advantages, there are drawbacks, too:

    • You have to pay for your table.
    • You have to prep your cards for sale sort them, put them in holders, price them.
    • You have to drive to the show .
    • You have to sit at the show all day.
    • You have to handle money , which can be fun AND stressful.
    • You have to account for sales tax if you dont have a dealer sales tax number, and there may be some promoters who wont allow you to set up without one.

    Youre absorbing the dealer costs yourself with this method of selling your baseball cards, the price you pay for calling all the shots.

    Also Check: Demarini The Goods Baseball Bat

    More articles

    Popular Articles