Mickey Mantle Baseball Card #50psa 8 Value: $3888
A 1964 Topps Mickey Mantle baseball card has a value ranging from $52,268 for a PSA 9 and $3,888 for a PSA 8. The 1964 Topps offer excellent eye appeal, but it is challenging to grade. PSA graded 8,719 Mickey Mantle baseball cards from the 1964 Topps set with one grading gem mint 10, 43 grading mint 9, and 507 grading PSA 8. The remainder graded PSA 7 or less. The most populated grade is PSA 6, with 1,502 graded.
1964 Topps Baseball Card Set
The 1964 Topps set is considered by many as being among one of Topps better-designed sets. Card fronts feature a large color photo that blends into a top panel containing the team name, while a panel below the picture provides the players names and positions. An exciting innovation on the back is a baseball quiz question requiring the collectors to rub a white panel revealing the answer rubbing the card with a coin led to many examples having damage resulting in condition issues.
Best Mickey Mantle Baseball Cards: The Ultimate Collectors Guide
If you collect Mickey Mantle baseball cards then you know one thing is for certain:
they aren’t cheap.
He was one of the most popular players of his era and an icon for one of the game’s all-time great franchises.
Mantle put up absolutely incredible numbers over his career…
And we’ll always wonder just how much better he might have been had he not suffered that fateful knee injury in the 1951 World Series.
Regardless, the Yankees icon and won the hearts of many fans. And that puts his baseball cards in very high demand.
And in this guide we’ll look at all his mainstream cards and some of my favorite oddball issues.
Let’s jump right in!
Ross Uitts – Owner
Are you selling sports cards that were produced from 1868 – 1975?
If so, then please fill out the form below and I’ll be in touch right away. Or, feel free to call/text me at 305-684-6680!
Mickey Mantle Baseball Card #95psa 8 Value: $17400
A near-mint PSA 8 graded 1957 Topps Mickey Mantle baseball card carries a value between $12,000 and $17,000. Before 2021, PSA 8 examples sold between $5,000 and $8,000 however, prices have doubled. Memory Lane sold a PSA 9 example for $209,793 in October 2021. There are 277 PSA 8s, 22 PSA 9s, and one PSA 10 in supply.
1957 Topps Baseball Card Set
1957 was the first year Topps began using the standard 2-½ x 3-½ size for cards. Another change came in the use of real color photographs instead of the hand-colored black and whites of previous years. For the first time since 1954, there were also cards with more than one player included. The two, Dodger Sluggers and Yankees Power Hitters, began a trend toward the increased use of multiple-player cards. Another first-time innovation found on the backs is complete player statistics. The scarce cards in the set are not the high numbers instead, they are numbers #265-352.
The Ghost of Babe Ruth
The Mickey Mantle 1957 Topps #95 is popular even though it is not a rare release. The image of the new hero won the hearts of fans, and the card sold well. When you look at it, you can see the Ghost of Babe Ruth, a phantom shape in the background. The leading theory is that the smear is a photoshopped, aka a blacked-out maintenance man who got into the way of the photo. The ghost-like fixture has led to this cards fame and importance.
Read Also: Rawlings Pro 150 Baseball Pants
Mickey Mantle Baseball Card #10psa 8 Value: $8501
The value of a 1959 Topps Mickey Mantle baseball card graded PSA 8 is roughly $8,500. Prices are down from the beginning of 2021 when Heritage Auctions set the all-time high price for a PSA 8 at $12,000. A PSA 9 example was recently sold at auction in February 2022 for $98,562. The 59 Topps set is a relatively challenging set to grade. PSA graded 8,437 Mantle cards with one grading gem mint 10, 25 mint 9, and 321 grading near-mint 8. The most populated grade is PSA 4, with 1,547 graded.
1959 Topps Baseball Card Set
1959 Topps has a round photograph on the front with a solid-color background above and below and a white border. Furthermore, a facsimile autograph runs across each photo. The 572-card set marks the most extensive set issued at the time. Card numbers below 507 have red and green printing on the back with the card number in white inside a green box.
On high number cards beginning with #507, the printing is black and red, and the card number is in a black box. Specialty cards include multi-player cards, team cards with checklists on the back, All-Star cards, Baseball Thrills, and 31 Rookie Stars. Card numbers 199-286 can have either white or gray backs, with the gray stock being less common.
Mickey Mantle Baseball Card #311psa 8 Value: $1560000
A 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle baseball card is the Holy Grail of baseball cards. Therefore, the value is astronomical regardless of the condition it is in. Heritage Auctions sold a PSA 9 mint condition example at auction in April 2018 for $2,880,000. PSA graded 1,825 of the 52 Mickey Mantle rookie cards with three grading gem mint 10, six grading mint 9, and 35 grading near-mint to mint 8. The 52 Topps set is not the most difficult to grade, however, high-graded examples are relatively hard to come by. PSA 1 graded examples carry a value between $25,000 and $35,000.
1952 Topps Baseball Card Set
The 1952 Topps set is perhaps the most sought-after because of the new, bigger, and more colorful design that Topps pursued. Topps knew they would have to do something bold to compete with Bowman. So, they overhauled their approach with the stunning 1952 Topps design. Each cards 2 5/8 x 3 3/4 measurements brought attention to the eyes.
It was a huge run of 407 cards a set which was the biggest that Topps had ever attempted. The cards were large, the massive set and the colors were bursting. Significant baseball card innovations in the set include the first-ever use of color team logos as part of the design and the inclusion of stats for the previous season and career on the backs.
Different backs on cards
1952 Topps dumped in the Hudson River
Also Check: Custom Baseball Jerseys No Minimum
Mickey Mantle Baseball Card #150psa 8 Value: $3120
A 1967 Topps Mickey Mantle baseball card, graded PSA 8, sells for around $3,000. The value tripled since the middle of 2020, when it held a value of $1,000. PSA graded 9,106 of the 67 Mantle cards. Of those submitted, two graded gem mint and 79 graded mint 9.
1967 Topps Baseball Card Set
One of the most popular sets of the 60s, Topps 1967 effort combines attractive cards with the real challenge of assembling a set that contains some scarce cards. More so than in most years, the high numbers in the 67 set are considerably scarcer than the other series. Part of the scarcity in the 67 highs is that some of the cards in that group are double printed, but collectors cant agree on which ones since Hall of Famer Brooks Robinson and rookie cards of Rod Carew and Tom Seaver appear in the high-number series.
The 1967 Topps set contains a whopping 609 cards, which, at the time, was Topps most extensive set. Card fronts look similar to the previous year except for the lack of colored backgrounds behind the team or player name. The backs were the first to be done vertically, although they continued to carry familiar statistical and biographical information.
Topps Mantle Blasts 565 Ft Home Run
This is another one of those cards that tough to associate with a particular set based on an initial visual inspection, and even the back is a bit confusing. Its a pretty cool little card, though, celebrating as it does the monster home run that Mantle blasted against the Washington Senators Chuck Stobbs on April 17, 1953. Any truth to the rumor that JFK, after hearing reports of this moonshot, recruited Mantle as a rocket booster in the US space program?
Also Check: Academy Of The Arts Baseball
Bowman Mickey Mantle #202
This is a unique card in that it celebrates a time when an emerging technology, television, was starting to change the world forever. Part of the Mantle mystique is that he was MVP for a team in the media capital of the world, at a time when a new medium was starting to take over and grow the game.
This card, all of which are greatly off-centered due to the inherent design of the issue, accurately conveys that. In researching this article, I spoke with a dealer at The National about Mantles cards and their valuation. Once we finished talking, she overtly tried to scam me. She excessively hyped up the once in a lifetime deal she was about to offer me: this card for $900 instead of the $1,000 they initially asked. All that hype and build-up for a discount of only 10%?
All I could say to this living, breathing New York stereotype was fuggedaboutit! I immediately took a walk and quickly saw this card priced elsewhere for $550.
Bowman Mickey Mantle #101
Again if you cant afford the 51 Bowman XRC, then get the next best thing from the very next year. Itll still set you back a few grand, but if you want to celebrate the Mantle myth, then this might be the card for you. The artist did a fantastic job of showcasing Mantle, the baseball player when that was all almost everybody knew of the man.
Mickey Mantle, the alcoholic, adulterous philanderer, and soul tortured by a family repeatedly stricken by severe illness are not reflected here. Nor should it be in baseball cards because, in these pieces of cardboard, we see the hero, not the actual human being.
Don’t Miss: Mens Size 12 Baseball Cleats
Sgc President Peter Steinberg Talks Grading The 1952 Topps Mantle
July 30, 2022 By Tony Reid
One of the highest grade examples of the most important and iconic post war sports card has created quite a buzz.
SGC president Peter Steinberg took time out of a busy schedule in the midst of the madness of The National to talk with us about the grading process, the magnitude and importance of the card and the significance of the fact that it resides in an SGC holder.
Tony Reid-SGC graded an incredible 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle card that scored a 9.5 Mint Plus. Its a piece of art and a piece of history as much as it is a baseball card. With a sale that will shatter any previous record for a single sports card offering. What was the environment and vibe in the office like when this one in a lifetime card walked in the door?
Peter Steinberg-We have graded hundreds of 1952 Topps Mantles. We have graded countless T206 Wagners. This one was just a different animal altogether. The eye appeal alone, remember this is before it has that beautiful 9.5 grade above it, the centering, the color, the corners, the registration, its all there on this card. This thing should not exist. The fact that is has such provenance and the fact that it has such a beautiful hobby lineage makes it that much sweeter.
TR-You mentioned the provenance, with the Mr. Mint letter and ownership of the card, how much more heat does that bring to an already spectacular card?
SGC President Peter Steinberg
For full coverage of the 2022 National, check out our special section.
Topps Mickey Mantle Collection Checklist Overview
The core of the release is a 50-card base set. The majority of these reprint past Topps and Bowman cards released during his playing career. Joining them are a handful of cards that never were. These take original Topps designs and fill in gaps where Mantle wasnt. These include 1951, 1954 and 1955 Topps, years where he was only in Bowman releases.
Bookending the checklist are cards using flagship designs from 2013 to 2021, years where Topps didnt initially have a deal with Mantles estate.
Parallels come in ten levels, all of which combine to land 1:5 packs:
- Yankee Blue /199
- Red /5
- Platinum 1/1
In addition to these are six Short Prints. For four of these, theyre essentially variations. The other two are unnumbered checklists.
Autographs can also be found, but theyre extremely scarce.
For starters, there are seven total Mantle cut signatures.
A dozen other Yankees stars and legends also have Monumental Autographs, all of which are also numbered to 7. Derek Jeter, Reggie Jackson and Mariano Rivera are among the headliners in the group.
Boxes are available through the Topps website. Each runs $9.99 for five cards.
Although the presentation is different and some elements are fresh, Mantle reprints have been done by Topps in the past. The most notable of these came in 1996 and 1997 when Topps made them one of the cornerstone inserts in their flagship line.
Recommended Reading: Signed Babe Ruth Baseball Value
Mickey Mantle Baseball Card #82psa 8 Value: $105000
A near-mint to mint 1953 Topps Mickey Mantle baseball card currently holds a value between $100,000 and $115,000. With such an attractive design coupled with the significance of being Mickeys second-year Topps card, its no wonder why. PSA graded 4,761 of the 53 Topps Mantle cards. Of those submitted, two graded gem mint 10, ten graded mint 9, and 94 graded PSA 8. The remainder graded PSA 7 or less with the most populated grade being PSA 4. Willie Mays is another great player to invest in from this set.
1953 Bowman Baseball Card Set
The 1953 Topps set reflects the companys continuing legal battles with Bowman. Originally intended to consist of 280 cards, the set lacks six numbers representing players whose contracts were lost to the competition. The 2- x 3-¾ cards feature painted player pictures. A color team logo appears on the bottom panel .
Card backs contain the first baseball card trivia questions, brief statistics, and player biographies. Cards numbered #1-165 have a noticeably larger supply, while cards numbered #221-280 have a much smaller supply.
The last Topps Mickey Mantle baseball card until 1956
Mickey Mantle Topps Baseball Cards
$2.85 FREE shippingAdd to Favorites
$17.00 FREE shippingAdd to Favorites
$29.45 FREE shippingAdd to Favorites
$29.95 FREE shippingAdd to Favorites
$24.99Add to Favorites
$586.99Add to Favorites
$28.00Add to Favorites
$310.00 FREE shippingAdd to Favorites
$14.95 FREE shippingAdd to Favorites
You May Like: Minor League Baseball Coaching Jobs
Top 10 Most Notable Mickey Mantle Cards
Mickey Mantle passed away well over a quarter-century ago, but his idol status has not waned at all.
At the 41st annual National Sports Collectibles Convention, just last month in Rosemont, IL, you could truly see and hear what makes Mantle such an immortal, timeless legend.
Panel discussions at The National discussed the hobby Mt. Rushmore, and The Mick was a consensus pick, along with Michael Jordan.
Who completes the fab four is debatable, but certainly Tom Brady, Ken Griffey Jr., Honus Wagner, Babe Ruth, and Lebron James are leading contenders.
Mantles 1952 Topps Rookie Card is without a doubt a first-ballot hobby hall of fame card.
Numerous trading card dealers and auction houses have it as their company logo or social media avatar.
Topps Mickey Mantle Rookie Card #311
We spoke with Eric Norton, of Beckett Media, by phone a week after an inferior condition version of this card could still command five figures at auction.
It didnt even have a grade on it, said Norton. It was just labeled as authentic looked like it had been run through the wringer, it was beaten up. It had scotch tape on it, scratched, creased, it was disgusting, and it sold for almost $11,000. There are some cards that defy the logic , but there are not many, and that 52 Mantle is one of them.
A PSA one version of this card can be had for about $55,000. A VG/PSA 3 typically costs around $90,000, and a mint edition will cost you well into six figures. A significant reason why this card is so special is its scarcity. Even if it was manufactured scarcity, and how that happened is a great story all within itself.
Mantle appeared in the higher numbered portion of the set, which had trouble selling due to its competing with football and football season. The problem got so bad that a severe backlog developed in the Topps warehouse. By 1960, the action taken, led by Topps designer Sy Berger, was to organize a barge to go into the East River, others say the Atlantic Ocean, and dump crates and crates full of 1952 Topps high numbers into the body of water.
You May Like: When Will Baseball Season Start 2022
Mickey Mantle Baseball Card Sells For Record $52 Million
Mickey Mantle or Mike Trout?
It’s an ongoing comparison between the Baseball Hall of Famer and three-time American League MVP as Trout’s career has progressed. But when it comes to baseball cards, Mantle now holds the crown.
Mantle’s 1952 mint condition Topps baseball card sold for a record $5.2 million through PWCC Marketplace last November, smashing the previous record for a trading card held by Trout.
Trout’s 2009 Bowman autographed rookie card sold for $3.9 million in August, making it the highest-selling sports card until now.
I’ve dreamt of owning a 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle since I was a kid collecting cards, said Rob Gough, the entrepreneur/actor who bought the card. It’s the Mona Lisa of sports cards and Ive been searching for this high graded example talking to industry experts, dealers, auction houses, friends and Im ecstatic that Im now the proud owner of this iconic card.
Mantle’s 1952 Topps card was graded by Professional Sports Authenticator as a 9 on a scale of 10 and is one of only six in existence. It’s captured the attention of serious collectors in recent years and sold for $2.88 million in 2018, becoming the-then second-highest price ever paid for a card, falling short of the $3.12 million a collector paid for a 1909 T206 Honus Wagner card in October 2016.
The card is also one of the few that survived from being dumped into the Atlantic Ocean.